compose an analytical case study about a specific strategic decision made by a particular organisation. Your specific objectives are to:
1. Describe the decision.
2. Explain why the organisation made it.
3. Evaluate the ethics of the decision and suggest what the organisation could have done differently.
Technical Challenge: Engineers reportedly found it technically difficult, if not impossible, to produce a mass-market diesel engine that was both cost-effective, fuel-efficient, powerful, and compliant with stringent U.S. emissions regulations. The technology required to achieve true "clean diesel" performance in real-world conditions was expensive and would have compromised the vehicle's performance—a trade-off the company was unwilling to make.
Competitive Pressure: Volkswagen saw an opportunity to gain a significant competitive advantage over rivals. By marketing its cars as both "clean" and high-performing, it could appeal to environmentally conscious consumers without sacrificing the power and efficiency that were hallmarks of diesel engines. The decision to use a defeat device was a shortcut to achieve this marketing promise.
The ethical evaluation of Volkswagen's decision is overwhelmingly negative. It represents a profound violation of several ethical principles:
Honesty and Integrity: The decision was based on a deliberate act of deception. The company lied to regulators, governments, and, most importantly, its customers. This destroyed public trust and caused immense reputational damage.
Social Responsibility: The decision showed a blatant disregard for public health and the environment. The excess NOx emissions contributed significantly to air pollution, which is linked to a range of health issues, including respiratory diseases and cardiovascular problems.
Corporate Governance: The scandal revealed a culture where pressure to meet targets outweighed ethical considerations. It indicated a systemic failure of leadership and oversight that allowed unethical practices to persist.
What Volkswagen could have done differently:
Instead of resorting to fraud, Volkswagen could have pursued several more ethical and sustainable strategic paths:
Acknowledge and Innovate: The company could have publicly acknowledged the technical challenges of developing a truly clean diesel engine and invested more heavily in research and development to overcome them.
This case study analyzes a strategic decision made by the Volkswagen Group, a multinational automotive manufacturer. The decision, which came to be known as "Dieselgate," involved the deliberate installation of "defeat devices" in its diesel engines to cheat on emissions tests.
In the mid-2000s, Volkswagen's leadership set an ambitious strategic goal: to become the world's largest carmaker by sales by 2018. A key part of this plan was a major push into the American market, where diesel cars had a reputation for being "dirty" and unreliable. To overcome this perception, Volkswagen's engineers were tasked with creating a "clean diesel" engine that could meet strict U.S. emissions standards while still offering the fuel efficiency and performance that consumers expected.
The core strategic decision was not to simply build a better engine but to resort to deception. Engineers developed and installed a sophisticated software program in the engine control units of millions of diesel vehicles. This software could detect when a car was being tested in a laboratory setting (by monitoring factors like steering wheel position, speed, and duration of the test). During the test, the software would activate a low-emissions mode, making the engine run cleaner and meet the legal requirements. However, in real-world driving conditions, the software would switch off the emissions controls, allowing the engines to emit nitrogen oxides (NOx) at levels up to 40 times the legal limit.
Volkswagen made this decision for a combination of strategic, technical, and commercial reasons.
Strategic Ambition: The primary driver was the company's aggressive goal of becoming the global market leader. This target, set by then-CEO Martin Winterkorn, created immense pressure on all departments to succeed, particularly in a crucial market like the U.S.
Embark on a journey of academic success with Legit Writing. Trust us with your first paper and experience the difference of working with world-class writers. Spend less time on essays and more time achieving your goals.
Order Now