Oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorders
The DSM is based on a medical model framework. Critique the diagnosis and treatment of oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorders. Remember how oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder are tied greatly to the environment, are we pathologizing social injustice?
Sample Solution
The diagnosis and treatment of oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and conduct disorders (CD) have been widely critiqued for a variety of reasons. This includes the fact that these conditions are almost exclusively diagnosed in low income, minority communities which has raised questions about whether or not they are being used to pathologize social injustice.
When it comes to the diagnosis of ODD and CD, many believe that too much emphasis is placed on behaviors rather than looking at underlying causes or environmental factors. It is widely accepted that both ODD and CD can be attributed to an individual’s environment and experiences, yet traditional diagnostic techniques often neglect this important factor. By only focusing on observable behaviors, issues such as poverty, racism, inadequate access to resources could all be missed when diagnosing these conditions.
In terms of treatment, there has also been criticism due to the fact that most interventions use a strictly medical model approach which fails to address any environmental issues within the home or community. Most treatments involve medication or cognitive behavioral therapy with very little focus on external factors that can influence behavior such as peer pressure or neighborhood violence. This type of one-size-fits-all approach may overlook certain aspects of a person’s life which could be contributing to their symptoms but are not addressed through traditional medical models.
Overall, current diagnostic techniques for ODD and CD may fail to consider external factors while treatment approaches may limit intervention options for those facing more complex circumstances related to their condition than what is usually considered through a strictly medical model framework. Ultimately if we wish for effective interventions for individuals suffering from ODD and CD then it is essential we take into account all aspects of their lives including any potential social injustices they may face so we can develop tailored plans suited towards helping them reach optimal levels of functioning in society instead pathologizing them due entirely by their perceived ‘deviance’ from normative standards of behavior