The Brothel Boy

  “George Orwell’s depiction of the Burmese in ‘The Brothel Boy’ is racist.” Discuss    
portrayal may be accurate in some respects, there is evidence that his views are also heavily colored by racism and prejudice. Thus, it can be argued that his depiction of the Burmese is indeed racist. At first glance, Orwell’s language appears to be relatively neutral when discussing the Burmese people; he speaks admiringly of their hardiness and resilience in the face of adversity and uses phrases such as “they got along very well” or “they had grown used to it.” However, upon closer inspection one finds instances where this neutrality falls away and a less sympathetic attitude emerges: for example, when describing how natives will accept any form of punishment without complaint he says “it was part of their nature.” This implies that they are somehow genetically predisposed to submission which serves only to reinforce racial stereotypes about Asians being passive and weak-willed. Furthermore, throughout his narrative he consistently refers to them as an undifferentiated mass rather than individuals; he focuses more on collective traits such as superstition or clannishness than individual characteristics like intelligence or ambition—a technique which places further emphasis on their difference from Europeans while downplaying any shared humanity between them both. Moreover, when discussing local customs such as Buddhism or animism—which many Westerners would have found 'strange' at the time—he does not engage with any understanding but instead quickly dismisses them as nonsensical beliefs only held by uncivilised peoples; here again there is a clear sense of superiority underlying his words which comes across strongly even today. This lack of empathy towards other cultures reveals itself most prominently at moments where Orwell expresses open contempt for certain aspects such as gambling or prostitution which were commonplace within Burma but frowned upon elsewhere (and vice versa). Such judgements clearly reveal an unwillingness to judge fairly based solely on common cultural standards but rather allow personal bias informed by race influence his opinion in ways both subtle and overt (for instance calling these customs ‘barbarous'). To conclude then yes it can be argued that George Orwell's depiction of the Burmese in "The Brothel Boy" contains elements which could be considered racist if viewed through modern lenses due its implicit condescension towards those who inhabit different worlds from our own coupled with often Eurocentric interpretations thereof . Admittedly this analysis may appear harsh given its focus on negative aspects yet ultimately one must bear witness both good and bad if we wish better understand history accurately—this point perhaps being best summarised by one final quote from Orwell himself: ""We have all got our private notions about foreign countries…But until geographical knowledge becomes identical with human understanding no theory will cover every case."

Sample Solution

    In the essay “The Brothel Boy,” George Orwell paints a vivid picture of life in British-ruled Burma, focusing on the mistreatment of Burmese citizens by their colonial overlords. In particular, he highlights how native people were often subjected to arbitrary and oppressive laws designed to keep them in subjection. While Orwell's

Unlock Your Academic Potential with Our Expert Writers

Embark on a journey of academic success with Legit Writing. Trust us with your first paper and experience the difference of working with world-class writers. Spend less time on essays and more time achieving your goals.

Order Now