The exploitation of us college athletes
https://www.ted.com/talks/tim_nevius_the_exploitation_of_us_college_athletes
The successful analysis will include the following key elements:
o A specific thesis statement that makes a quality judgment on whether or not the chosen speech is effective at achieving its purpose.
o A discussion of intended audience
o Who is the intended audience? How do you know? What specific sentences or phrases in the speech lead you to this conclusion?
o A discussion of the speaker's credibility
o How does the speaker indicate experience or expertise on the subject at hand?
o A discussion of strategies used in the speech meant to strengthen the speaker's message
o Does the speaker appeal to the audience's emotions? How? Does the speaker try to bond with the audience? How? Does the speaker try to appeal to the audience's logic? How?
o A works cited page with a MLA or APA-style citation for the chosen speech
Sample Solution
In his TED Talk, “The Exploitation of US College Athletes”, Tim Nevius effectively makes a case for the need to address unfairness in college athletics. He argues that college athletes are treated as commodities and exploited by universities and institutions, with little regard for their well-being or life after sports. Nevius’s thesis is clear: athletes deserve more protection from the NCAA and should be able to benefit financially from
the use of their name, image, and likeness (NIL). By highlighting both positive aspects of collegiate athletics—such as a sense of camaraderie—and negative ones—such as lack of due process rights or financial compensation—Nevius succeeds in addressing different points of view while reinforcing his own argument.
Throughout his talk, Nevius targets an audience composed mostly of young people who either have an interest in or may one day participate in college athletics. This is evidenced by phrases such as “you can make it work; you too can turn pro” that are likely meant to inspire current student-athletes and potential recruits. Furthermore, he references specific legislation targeting NIL rights which further reinforces the idea that this speech is catered towards students involved in collegiate sports.
The speaker demonstrates expertise on the subject through personal anecdotes about his experience working at the NCAA enforcement division where he witnessed firsthand how athletes were taken advantage of by organizations interested solely in their athletic prowess rather than providing them with proper protection. Additionally he cites numerous examples such as Ed O'Bannon's lawsuit against EA Sports for using athlete's likeness without permission and other similar disputes between colleges/universities & players which further bolster credibility on the speaker's part.
In order to strengthen his message throughout the talk, Nevius utilizes several rhetorical strategies including pathos or emotional appeal when recounting stories about student-athletes struggling financially despite playing a key role on their team; ethos or credibility when discussing recent cases involving NIL rights violations; logos or logical argumentation when outlining proposed solutions such as establishing minimum standards for player compensation; repetition when referencing terms like “fairness” throughout each section; vivid imagery regarding what it would take for someone to feel truly fulfilled by participating in college sports compared to those whose sole focus was winning & making money off it - all this being done so viewers could better relate & understand why something needs changing within existing system but also understand moral implications behind promoting fairness & equality among all participants regardless sport they play & level competition they compete at.. Finally, Nevius builds up tension over time until finally proposing radical changes necessary for long overdue reform - thus inspiring action among listeners willing go beyond just understanding info presented but actually do something bring rightful change into effect sooner rather than later..
Works Cited
Nevius ,Tim . "The Exploitation Of Us College Athletes." TED Talks , 03 Sept 2020,. Web Accessed 12 April 2021