Read police report and answer questions. This is what needs to be included.
An evidence inventory, which includes a list of evidence items collected by the police.
A summary of the results of analysis for each of the evidence items collected, including comparison to the appropriate reference samples, and conclusions about the possible source(s) of the evidence.
Questions to answer are in bold italics.
You will use these items to answer the following questions:
Questions:
(5) Draw a sketch of the scene based on the details provided in the police report. Start with the blank scene sketch at the end of this assignment sheet as the starting point for your sketch.
Identifying the hypotheses (scenarios) based on the stories of the two principals (what caused the problem):
These are the examples I highlighted
Lohan says:
Hilton says:
- Lohan had the paper they were working on together, and Hilton grabbed it. The paper tore
- Lohan writing gossip about her on a piece of paper, and Hilton tried taking the paper. The paper tore
Conflict: Project information on paper in either or both handwriting
Conflict: gossip on paper in Lohan’s writing
- Lohan crumpled her half and threw it at Hilton
- No comment on fate of paper
Conflict: crumpled paper
Conflict: no crumpling
- Lohan states that Hilton attacked her with pen
- Hilton says nothing about attacking Lohan
Conflict: Hilton attacks with pen
Conflict: Hilton would deny it
- Lohan says pen broke in her arm
- Hilton says nothing
Conflict: pen in Lohan’s arm
Conflict: no pen in arm
- Lohan says Hilton broke potted plant over Lohan’s head
- Hilton says Lohan struck her with potted plant
Conflict: Hilton broke potted plant on Lohan’s head
Conflict: Lohan struck Hilton with potted plant.
(10) What physical evidence exists to differentiate between the opposing hypotheses that you proposed? For each piece of evidence that could differentiate between the hypotheses, indicate what result would favour which hypothesis.
Results of the analysis, comparison, and conclusions is provided at the end of the Fashion Police Report.
Using the conflicting hypotheses in question 2:
(10) Which of your hypothesesare excluded as a result of the evidence examination results?
(10) Whose storyis supported by each item of evidence that you examine? Why?
(10) Prepare a short synopsis of your evidence examination relating which part of each story is supported by the evidence, and which is refuted by the evidence?