When a nation contemplates the use of force, that force must be done with legal authority and
within the strictures of the laws of armed conflict. If there is both legal authority and that force
follows the principles laid down by The Hague Rules of 1907 and the Geneva Conventions of
1949 then there can be a justified result. After September 11, 2001, Congress authorized the
Commander-in-Chief at the time to use force against those individuals who had perpetrated the
attack on the United States that fateful day. Under our constitutional scheme, the President
could direct the National Command Authority to use armed force against Al Qaeda, including
Bin Laden and others. Additional international authorizations via the United Nations and NATO
followed. Overlaid in this authorization to use force was the basic international principle of the
inherent right of a nation to self-defense, found in Art. 51 of the UN Charter. Domestically, the
authorized use of force was most certainly supported by a Presidential finding to kill Bin Laden
as a hostile. By law the President must inform the leadership in Congress about these findings.
This was done years prior to the operation itself. The operation was months in the making.
Intelligence officials discovered the compound in August while monitoring an al Qaeda courier.
The CIA had been hunting that courier for years. CIA interrogators in secret overseas prison
developed the first strands of information on him. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of
the September. 11, 2001 attacks, provided his name. The CIA got similar information from
Mohammed’s successor, Abu Faraj al-Libi. The detainees told interrogators that the courier was
so trusted by bin Laden that he might very well be living with the al Qaeda leader. By mid-
February, intelligence from multiple sources was clear enough that President Obama wanted to
“pursue an aggressive course of action,” a senior administration official said. Over the next two
and a half months, President Obama led five meetings of the National Security Council focused
solely on whether bin Laden was in that compound and, if so, how to get him. President Obama
met with his national security advisers on March 14, 2011 to create an action plan. President
Obama personally discussed the plan with Vice Admiral William McRaven, the commander of
the U.S. Joint Special Operations Command. The commander first approach considered was to
bomb the house using B-2 Spirit stealth bombers, which could drop 2,000-pound Joint Direct
Attack Munitions (JDAMs). Obama rejected this option, however, opting for a raid instead. This
would provide definitive proof that bin Laden was inside, and limit collateral damage. On April
29, 2011, President Obama approved an operation to kill bin Laden. It was a mission that
required surgical accuracy, even more precision than could be delivered by the government’s
sophisticated Predator drones. To execute it, President Obama tapped a small contingent of the
Navy’s elite SEAL Team Six and put them under the command of CIA Director Leon Panetta,
whose analysts monitored the compound from afar.
Operation Geronimo is the code name given to the raid conducted by the United States Special
Forces against Osama bin Laden’s safe house in the city of Abbottābad, Pakistan on May 1,
2011. Osama Bin Laden was killed during this operation. The operation was conducted by
members of the United States Navy SEAL Team Six, under the command of the Joint Special
Operations Command, in conjunction with U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) operatives.
The team had to go across the border of Afghanistan to launch the attack. During the month
leading up to the raid, members of the Naval Special Warfare Development Group (DEVGRU)
trained on a one-acre replica of the “Waziristan Mansion” compound in a special operations
sector of Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan, practicing rappelling down into it from helicopters,
among other tactical approaches. DEVGRU was a 24-man platoon. Bin Laden was in a highly
fortified compound in the Pakistani town of Abbottābad. Nestled in a neighborhood that also was
near Pakistani military academy and favored by retired military leaders, the compound was
surrounded by walls as high as 18 feet, topped with barbed wire. Two security gates guarded
the only way in. A third-floor terrace was shielded by a seven-foot privacy wall. No phone lines
or Internet cables ran to the property. The residents burned their garbage rather than put it out
for collection. Intelligence officials believed the million-dollar compound was built five years ago
to protect a major terrorist figure. The raid of the compound was less than 40 minutes.
Based on this scenario;
You will chose one side to persuade your reader of: President Obama had the legal authority to
order Operation Geronimo and to execute the plan or President Obama did not have the legal
authority to order Operation Geronimo and to execute the plan.